Publication Ethics and Publication Malpractice Statement

The NTU Journal of Renewable Energy (NTU-JRE) is a peer-reviewed, open-access scientific journal committed to maintaining the highest standards of publication ethics, transparency, integrity, and academic excellence throughout the editorial and publication process.
The journal follows the principles and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and applies the COPE Core Practices in all aspects of editorial management, peer review, publication, and post-publication activities.
The journal also follows internationally accepted standards of ethical publishing and editorial independence to ensure fairness, transparency, confidentiality, and accountability.
For further guidance, please refer to:
COPE Core Practices
https://publicationethics.org/core-practices
COPE Flowcharts
https://publicationethics.org/guidance/Flowcharts⁠
Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)
https://publicationethics.org/⁠


COPE Core Practices
NTU-JRE applies the following COPE Core Practices throughout the publication process:
1-Editorial Responsibility and Accountability
2-Authorship and Contributorship
3-Complaints and Appeals
4-Conflicts of Interest
5-Data and Reproducibility
6-Ethical Oversight
7-Intellectual Property
8-Journal Management
9-Peer Review Processes
10-Post-publication Discussions and Corrections


Publisher's Responsibilities
The publisher supports editorial independence and is committed to maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record.
The publisher shall:
- Support editors in maintaining editorial independence.
- Protect academic freedom.
- Ensure ethical publishing standards are maintained.
- Provide appropriate publishing infrastructure.
- Maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts.
- Publish corrections, retractions, or expressions of concern when required.
- Cooperate with editors during investigations of publication misconduct.


Editor's Responsibilities
Editors are responsible for making fair, unbiased, and independent editorial decisions based solely on scientific merit.
Editors shall:
- Handle all manuscripts confidentially.
- Ensure a fair and timely double-blind peer-review process.
- Evaluate manuscripts without discrimination.
- Avoid conflicts of interest.
- Maintain reviewer confidentiality.
- Reject manuscripts involving plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabricated or falsified data, or unethical research.
- Issue corrections or retractions whenever necessary.
- Follow COPE recommendations when handling ethical concerns.


Reviewer's Responsibilities
Reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the scientific quality of the journal.
Reviewers shall:
- Conduct reviews objectively and professionally.
- Maintain complete confidentiality.
- Declare any conflict of interest.
- Decline reviews outside their expertise.
- Identify plagiarism or ethical concerns whenever detected.
- Avoid using unpublished material for personal benefit.
- Submit reviews within the agreed timeframe.


Author's Responsibilities
Authors must submit original, unpublished work that is not under consideration elsewhere.
Authors are responsible for:
- Ensuring the originality of submitted work.
- Properly citing all sources.
- Avoiding plagiarism and duplicate publication.
- Reporting research accurately and honestly.
- Retaining original research data when requested.
- Obtaining all required ethical approvals.
- Identifying all eligible co-authors.
- Approving the final manuscript before submission.
- Promptly notifying the journal if significant errors are discovered after publication.


Conflicts of Interest
All authors, reviewers, editors, and editorial board members must disclose any financial, institutional, professional, or personal relationships that could influence their decisions or the interpretation of research findings.
Whenever a conflict exists, the individual concerned must declare it and recuse themselves from the editorial or review process whenever appropriate.


Research Integrity
NTU-JRE is committed to preserving the integrity of the scholarly record.
Editorial decisions are based exclusively on:
- Scientific quality
- Originality
- Technical validity
- Ethical compliance
- Relevance to the journal scope
No decision shall be influenced by nationality, gender, religion, institutional affiliation, or political beliefs.


Research Misconduct
NTU-JRE investigates all allegations of publication misconduct in accordance with the COPE Core Practices and COPE Flowcharts.
Research misconduct includes, but is not limited to:
- Plagiarism
- Data fabrication
- Data falsification
- Duplicate publication
- Redundant publication
- Citation manipulation
- Image manipulation
- Authorship manipulation
- Undisclosed conflicts of interest
- Ethical violations involving human or animal research


Where misconduct is confirmed, the journal may:
- Reject the manuscript.
- Request corrections.
- Publish an Erratum or Corrigendum.
- Publish an Expression of Concern.
- Retract the article.
- Notify the author's institution where appropriate.


Human and Animal Research Ethics
Research involving human participants or animals must comply with internationally recognized ethical standards.
Authors must clearly state:
- Ethics committee approval.
- Approval number (where applicable).
- Informed consent for human participants.
- Compliance with the Declaration of Helsinki for human research.
- Compliance with institutional or national animal welfare guidelines.


Data Availability
Authors are encouraged to make research data available whenever possible.
The manuscript should include a Data Availability Statement indicating where supporting data can be accessed or explaining any restrictions.


Artificial Intelligence (AI)
Authors must disclose any use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools during manuscript preparation.
AI tools cannot be listed as authors and remain the responsibility of the human authors.


Appeals and Complaints
Authors may appeal editorial decisions or submit complaints regarding editorial procedures.
All appeals and complaints will be handled fairly, confidentially, and in accordance with the COPE Core Practices.


Corrections and Retractions
NTU-JRE is committed to maintaining the accuracy of the scholarly record.
Where necessary, the journal publishes:
- Corrections
- Errata
- Corrigenda
- Expressions of Concern
- Retractions
following COPE recommendations.


Copyright and Intellectual Property
Authors retain responsibility for the originality of their work.
The journal respects intellectual property rights and investigates all allegations of copyright infringement, plagiarism, or unauthorized reproduction in accordance with COPE guidance.